TheManCalledScott’s Highest-Rated Games

This page highlights the highest scoring video games as reviewed by Wizard Dojo’s beloved founder, TheManCalledScott.


The 10s

Very few games exude the nearly flawless polish and creativity that justifies a perfect score. As far as the Dojo is concerned, these are those games.

Keep in mind that , although a number of these games have been reviewed relatively close together, the timeframes between the releases of a 10 can be extensive. So don’t expect this pace of perfect scores to continue.

There are currently games to have earned a 10.

Super Mario Galaxy 2

Reviewed on: May 23, 2015 

“Super Mario Galaxy 2 is a celebration of video games. The end result is not only the best 3D platformer yet made, it’s also one of the finest video games of all time.” Read the full review


Super Mario World

Reviewed on: September 18, 2015

“Super Mario World is both a refinement and a subtle but powerful reinvention of everything Mario learned up to that point. It remains not only one of the best Mario games ever, but one of the greatest video games. Period.” Read the full review


Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy’s Kong Quest

Reviewed on: November 20, 2015

“You won’t find many games that are built so strongly around such contrasts, and none that execute them better, or provide this much fun while doing it.” Read the full review

Castlevania: Symphony of the Night

Reviewed on: December 21, 2015

“With its release, the ‘Metroidvania’ genre came to full fruition, and it could easily be argued that Symphony of the Night is still the peak of the genre.” Read the full review

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

Reviewed on: April 5, 2017

“Despite all of its inspirations, Breath of the Wild is still very much the same Zelda experience we all know and love. In fact, it may just be the best of the legendary lot.” Read the full review

Super Mario Odyssey

Reviewed on: October 29, 2017

“Odyssey has pulled it off all over again. Its restless imagination, non-stop surprises, and pitch-perfect gameplay will leave anyone wondering what the future holds for Mario and company.”  Read the full review


Reviewed on: April 8, 2018*

“When Toby Fox created Undertale, he molded his game after some all-time greats in the RPG genre. Little did he know that his “little” game would end up sitting right alongside them.” Read the full review 

Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars

Reviewed on: June 19, 2018

“Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars can at least still claim to be among Mario’s greatest adventures, and one of the best RPGs of all time. A legend indeed.” Read the full review


The 9.5s

Though the “near-perfect” score of 9.5 may not be quite as rare as a 10, they are still few and far between. They may not boast that perfect score, but they still deserve to stand side-by-side next to any 10. There are currently a total of games that have earned a 9.5 by Wizard Dojo’s original author, TheManCalledScott.


 Super Smash Bros. for Wii U

Reviewed on: January 1, 2015

“Whether you’re old enough to get all the references or the Wii U is your first foray into the worlds of Nintendo, Super Smash Bros. for Wii U has something for everybody.” Read the full review 


Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze

Reviewed on: February 21, 2015 (Wii U)

“It can get tough, but for those willing to embrace its challenges, Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze is a modern showcase of classic game design at its best.” Read the full review 

Reviewed on: May 10, 2018 (Switch)

“Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze should rank among the best games Nintendo has ever made. And hopefully this time, more people will get to realize that.” Read the full review


Super Mario 64

Reviewed on: March 30, 2015

“Super Mario 64 is still one of gaming’s wonderlands.” Read the full review


Mega Man 2

Reviewed on: May 18, 2015

“Video games have come a long way since Mega Man 2 was first released in 1989. But in so many ways, Mega Man 2 is still one of the all-time greats.” Read the full review


Super Mario Bros. 3

Reviewed on: September 16, 2015

“Super Mario Bros. 3 remains one of the greatest platformers ever made, one of the crown jewels of 8-bit gaming, and one of the finest games to don the Mario name.” Read the full review



Reviewed on: February 29, 2016

“Bloodborne is nonetheless one of the best exclusives to be released on any Playstation console. For those with the patience for it, it’s well worth it.” Read the full review


Dark Souls III

Reviewed on: April 29, 2016

“It may not reinvent the series, but if this is truly to be its final installment, then Dark Souls III is a hell of a way to go out, solidifying the series as one of the most consistent, and richest, in gaming history.” Read the full review


Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End

Reviewed on: May 16, 2016

“This isn’t just Nathan Drake’s last ride, it’s also a culmination of Naughty Dog’s accomplishments that started over two decades ago, on the shoulders of a bandicoot.” Read the full review


Mario Kart 8 Deluxe

Reviewed on: May 4, 2017

“Mario Kart 8 was already the closest thing the series had to a definitive entry, and now as Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, it undoubtedly belongs on any list of the best Nintendo games.” Read the full review


*Undertale was initially reviewed on February 1, 2016. The original review, now upped to a 10/10 to reflect my current standing, can be found here.